Reynolds vs. Reynolds: The Cereal Defense

"Reynolds vs. Reynolds: The Cereal Defense" is the tenth and final episode of the eight season of the American television sitcom It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, and is the 94th overall episode. It was written by Charlie Day, Glenn Howerton and series creator Rob McElhenney, directed by Richie Keen and aired on FX on December 20, 2012.^[1]

In this episode, Frank (Danny DeVito) and Dennis (Howerton) stage a mock trial after Frank crashes his car into Dennis' while Dennis was eating cereal at a red light. Dee (Kaitlin Olson) intititally acts as Dennis' lawyer, and Charlie (Day) as Frank's, with Mac (McElhenney) being the judge/bailiff.

Plot

While parked at a red traffic light, Dennis (Howerton) is eating cereal in his car when Frank (DeVito) crashes into him. This causes Dennis to spill his cereal all over the inside of his car. Due to their dispute over whether or not Frank will pay for the damages, the Gang decides to throw a mock trial to decide the outcome. Dee (Olson) acts as Dennis' lawyer, and Charlie (Day) acts as Frank's, with Mac (McElhenney) as the judge/bailiff.

Firstly, Charlie, defending Frank, gets Dennis to admit that anyone who is "donkey-brained" would be unsafe to drive. Charlie then produces a legal document from Frank's childhood which says Frank doesn't have "donkey brains" after he was wrongfully committed to a mental institution. Charlie uses the document to prove Frank's sound state of mind, while arguing that Dennis' lack of such a document means he could be a "donkey-brained man".

Dennis begins his argument by offering Frank a glass of wine. He then hits Frank, causing him to spill the wine. Dennis claims the accident was his fault, and that he'd pay for the damages. Mac then argues that Frank assumed responsibility when he took the wine, and that he knew risks, meaning it was his fault for the incident. Dee then challenges the argument by questioning Mac's credibility as a witness. Dee manipulates Charlie's feelings towards Mac by bringing up their disagreements on superheroes. Dee attempts to get Mac to admit that he believes he could create a race of superhumans through evolution to change Charlie's opinion, but Mac explains he was joking, and that it could never happen in the real world. Dennis questions Mac's reasoning for not believing in superhumans, to which he answers that evolution doesn't exist.

Three hours later, Mac brings out a poster he made in an attempt to convince the Gang that evolution is a lie. Dennis tells Mac that he'll never convince them that evolution isn't real because all the smartest scientists say it's real, to which Mac lists examples of when scientists have been wrong, discrediting Aristotle, Galileo and Isaac Newton. Mac compares his faith in the Bible to Dennis' faith in science, which sways the Gang to have doubts about evolution. After not reaching an agreement, Frank and Dennis perform a re-enactment of the incident, where Frank crashes into Dennis' car again. The Gang (except Dee) unanimously decides that Dee is at fault, and should pay for the damages.

Production

The episode was written by executive producers Charlie Day and Glenn Howerton, with series creator Rob McElhenney, all of whom are main actors in the series. It was directed by Richie Keen, and was the last episode to be filmed of the season.^[1]

Reception

The episode was watched by 0.94 million viewers on its intital airing.^[2] The episode received positive reviews from critics. IGN called the episode "doing what they do best", and rated it 8.6/10.^[3] Paste Magazine rated the episode 7.9/10.^[4]

References