Commons:Deletion requests/Files in Category:Statues and Reliquaries of Blessed Carlo Acutis in the Philippines

Statues of a holy figure who died in 2006 and beatified in 2020. Hence the sculptors aren't likely dead for more than 50 years. The nature of the sculptures makes it difficult to determine if these were meant to be "situated otherwise than temporarily" (which makes them eligible for future {{FoP-Philippines}}) or not. See also: Commons:Deletion requests/Files uploaded by RamaGaspar#Files uploaded by RamaGaspar (talk · contribs) 4.

• File:Carlo Acutis Baliwag Fiesta Patronales 2022 16.jpg
• File:Carlo Acutis.jpg
• File:Statue of Blessed Carlo Acutis, in the Philippines.jpg
• File:Statues and Reliquaries of Blessed Carlo Acutis in the Philippines 01.jpg
• File:Statues and Reliquaries of Blessed Carlo Acutis in the Philippines 02.jpg
• File:Statues and Reliquaries of Blessed Carlo Acutis in the Philippines 03.jpg
• File:Statues and Reliquaries of Blessed Carlo Acutis in the Philippines 04.jpg
• File:Statues and Reliquaries of Blessed Carlo Acutis in the Philippines 05.jpg

JWilz12345 (Talk|Contrib's.) 14:21, 12 October 2022 (UTC)[reply]

 Delete per above. Bedivere (talk) 18:59, 14 October 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Comment and opposition: In my humble view, I am submitting the grounds to Keep: a) the Pilgrim Carlo Acutis Reliquary (Baliuag Church) and Statue are parts of The Tour, “Byahe ni Kuya Carlo”; b) on April 19, 2021, Bishop Dennis Cabanada Villarojo, D.D., Ph.D., granted the petition of the Biyahe ni Kuya Carlo Movement of the Friends of Blessed Carlo Acutis Philippines to be the movement’s Bishop Promoter; c) On July 27, 2022 Bishop Villarojo officiated the Solemn Liturgical Reception of the new pilgrim relic] ex corpore et ex capilis (from the body and hair), a d) Gift from the Roman Catholic Diocese of Assisi-Nocera Umbra-Gualdo Tadino and the Associazione Amici di Carlo Acutis;” e) led by Hermano Mayor Mackee Tengco Burgos (2nd child of Victoria Rodriguez Tengco-Burgos, with siblings Vicsi and Vimmy Tengco-Burgos), f) clearly the Carlo Acutis statue's and reliquary's ownership including all other remaining rights to these, are absolutely transfered via Donation Inter Vivos by Diocese to Diocese to the Tengcos-Biyahe ni Kuya Carlo Movement of the Friends of Blessed Carlo Acutis Philippines to be the movement’s Bishop Promoter; g) ad cautelam and asssuming for the sake of argument that the Bureau of Copyright and its legal division vis-à-vis the Phil Copyright law are consulted, the Transferors foreigners are not protected and they cannot enforce any right under the Philippine law; g) for instance, the transferor would file a copyright violation in the Bureau of Copyright, forthwith that would be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction or legal personality; h) the sculpture and reliquary were and are meant to promote Carlo Acutis for Canonization by the owner Tengcos as Promoter in all the areas under the jurisdiction of the Diocese of Malolos; i) Blessed Carlo Acutis wooden sculpture by Felman Limlengco Bagalso of Paete, Laguna is another story, unlike the foreign Gift to the Tengcos; since there is no copyright violation which can be invoked by any foreign architect etc.; regrettably I humbly oppose the deletion for lack of utter merit, sincerely RamaGaspar (talk) 07:11, 17 October 2022 (UTC).[reply]

@RamaGaspar: what matters is the copyright of the sculptors, the issue on church property is irrelevant since the church administration were not its creators or designers. Even then, the church can acquire copyright from the sculptors via contract so even then the artworks are still not in public domain. JWilz12345 (Talk|Contrib's.) 09:19, 17 October 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Deleted: per nomination. ✗plicit 14:25, 11 November 2022 (UTC)[reply]